User talk:NoName

From Melvor Idle
Revision as of 00:48, 17 September 2024 by Auron956 (talk | contribs) (→‎Money Making Guide Edits: new section)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)

Money Making Guide Edits

Apologies, but I'm going revert some of your more recent edits, as I don't believe them to meet the quality standards of the wiki.

This edit to an existing guide has a few issues:

  • It has been placed above the table of contents and almost all of the page's existing content, which isn't suitable. Given that it builds on the "Basic" and "Absolute Max" methods the guide describes, I would suggest it be contained within its own section below these two existing sections
  • The setup to achieve the stated outcome isn't adequately documented. an "Abyssal Magic set" is referenced, however there is no such documented equipment set upon the page
  • The edit adds a date stamp to the page's content, which is unnecessary

In addition, I must insist that this money making guide remains within the User namespace until it is improved upon. I appreciate that a call to action for other contributors to improve upon the page has been placed upon the page its self, but regardless this does not mean it can be accepted in its current state.

  • The use of Template:MoneyMakingGuide has a number of invalid parameters, resulting in the template returning a number of errors and parts which do not appear as intended. Please refer to other existing guides which make use of this template in the intended way
  • Once again, the equipment set (and any supporting Agility obstacles, potions, and so on) isn't documented. Ideally a list of equipment which should or could be used should be included, simply stating that the reader should "Build equipment around the pirate pants" and that the selected equipment should "reduce your attack power, increase your abyssal resistance, and decrease your attack interval" is quite vague given the large variety of equipment that is currently available

Happy to discuss further either here or in Discord if desired, thanks. Auron956 (talk) 00:48, 17 September 2024 (UTC)